The double-deck Duplex A86 tunnel near Paris, opened in 2009, gained a glowing report. (EuroTAP, Jan Potente, photographer)
Results show the state of Europe's tunnel infrastructure at its 'most sublime and most depressing quality' as Patrick Smith reports
The EU Tunnel Directive setting the minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the trans-European road networks was adopted in 2004.
EuroTAP says that despite significant progress made by many tunnel operators, practically 40% of tunnels tested in EuroTAP 2010 did not score top marks (www.eurotapmobility.com).
"We can see indications that some Member States will have an obvious problem to comply with the deadlines set by the EU Tunnel Directive by 2014 and 2019 respectively," said Wil Botman, director general of the FIA [Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile, the organisation of the world's leading motoring organisations] European Bureau. "It is necessary to speed up the process of refurbishment of tunnels already in operation in order to meet requirements of the Directive and to improve the safety of all motorists." EuroTAP claims that inadequate breathing equipment for fire fighters, a major shortcoming in half of all tunnels would make rescues in thick smoke impossible. Similarly, the frequently noted lack of tunnel loudspeakers makes warnings about accidents to drivers entering or already in the tunnel impossible. Missing hydrants and information displays at portals, no barriers to close the tunnel, dark tunnel walls and insufficient escape route signs were among the most common deficiencies, while 19% of tunnels lack appropriate lighting and in-tunnel traffic radio reception, conditions all motorists expect to function.
With motorisation across Europe expected to increase and not just in peak holiday periods, roads and tunnels will have to bear increasing daily volumes of vehicles and increased risks of accidents.
"This year's results show the state of Europe's tunnel infrastructure at its most sublime and most depressing quality. In last place out of the 26 tested tunnels is Iceland's [sub-sea] Hvalfjörður Tunnel. For this EU candidate country, EuroTAP can serve as a benchmark in its efforts to become an EU member and comply with EU legislation," says EuroTAP.
The Hvalfjördur Tunnel, on the south-west coast of Iceland, opened in 1998, reduced the travel distance between the capital Reykjavík and other localities by over 40km.
Plans for the future include (2010) improved markings for lay-bys; additional fire extinguishers and batteries for the uninterruptible power supply system to be supplemented/replaced. Next year additional video cameras and transmission via optical fibres; additional emergency phones with fire extinguishers and improved markings are planned, while in 2012 escape route signs in the tunnel and new cabling for evacuation lighting will be fitted.
Between 2012 and 2014 the installation of an automatic video surveillance system; an automatic extinguishing system in the transformer stations and certified cables for power supply and control are scheduled.
With traffic in the tunnel increasing by approximately 10-12%/year 2004-2007, it was felt a new tunnel was necessary in 2014-2015 but following the financial crisis in 2008, there has been no growth in traffic.
"All geological research and primary design for the new tunnel was ready in July, 2008 but now it is not on the plan in the public sector for the next 8-10 years," said Gylfi Thordarson, managing director of the tunnel operators Spölur ehf.
At the other end of the test results scale stands the state-of-the-art A86 Duplex Tunnel, part of a ring road around Paris. This exemplary and innovative double-deck tunnel with cross-connections and additional escape and rescue routes every 200m, offers the full range of safety features that other operators should target.
